Showing posts with label sourdough. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sourdough. Show all posts

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: A Disasterous Diagnosis

My starter has not been well, people. Not well at all.

It started out fabulously... lots of expansion and indication of wild yeast activity by day 3.


Then I switched from pineapple puree to just plain water. Things went flat, but then I found hooch. Oh, the hope I held in my heart...


That ushered a period of seeming inactivity, but I kept at it. I fed it every day, tried my best to keep it warm overnights in the microwave--and there, I believe, was the problem. It got too warm. There was one night in particular that Mr.W, in his well-meaning way, put The Beast to bed... but directly over the over-stove lightbulb. In the morning it was almost hot to the touch--my fear was the killer 100 degree (F) mark.

Several more days and various attempts to motivate the starter were unfruitful. Then, the final change: the gym sock smell.

Everything I read around the blogosphere about sourdough starter says that's bad mojo... so I've relegated this particular experiment to a watery grave in the sewer.

Although I feel some disappointment, I also think it was a really good first try. I should have been using whole grain flour, after all, and I was surprised to actually have had some success with plain old all-purpose flour. I did buy a bag of whole wheat flour a few days ago that I plan to use for another try... though I think I'll experiment and do the photos BEFORE posting the whole story, for fear of another public failure!

At any rate, thanks for sharing this experience with me, and the comments and emails that helped to encourage me along the way! I'm determined to figure this out--without use of commercial yeast--and with my previous success at capturing wild yeast I know it's possible.

Thursday, October 30, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: What's Going On?

Nothing, really. No news. My sad little starter has no growth, no changes. I'm still following the proscribed regimen: retain 1/4 cup, add 1/4 cup flour and 1/4 cup water. Stir. Leave 'til the next day.

I've been reassured that it might be the cool weather we're experiencing, or just a sluggish batch. But it's still going, still going, still going...


Other posts about my sourdough starter experiment:
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 8

Monday, October 27, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: Day 8

The weekend passed uneventfully for The Beast and I. Every day I kept a part of the existing starter--1/4 cup--then added 1/4 cup each AP flour and filtered water. And every day it produced aggressive bubbles and a layer of hooch.

Unfortunately, no growth.



Petite Kitchen's instructions suggest that somewhere between days 5 to 7 the mixture should be able to double itself within 8 hours, thus becoming usable for bread-baking.

Since mine stopped growth exactly when I stopped using pineapple puree, I'm wondering if something went very, very wrong. I don't think it's dead, though--because it still bubbles.

I'll give it a few more days. Keep your fingers crossed!


Read about The Beast:
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5

Friday, October 24, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: Day 5

I can't believe The Beast is already five days old. He's become sluggish--no more speedy growth now, though we have hooch.



Hooch is an alcoholic substance produced in the making of sourdough starter. All instructions that I've read say to stir it back in--so that's exactly what I did.

But not before a closer look.



Angry, angry beast! It bubbled and popped furiously while I took this picture.

So the hooch got stirred in, all but 1/4 cup was dumped down the drain, and I added another 1/4 cup each AP flour and filtered water.

It's seems that all is as it should be.



Read about my sourdough experiment from the beginning:

Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4

Thursday, October 23, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: Day 4

After yesterday's feeding my little kitchen monster became very active! It started to bubble and expand almost immediately--within a couple of hours it was almost to the top of the container! It stopped about a centimeter from the top, though, and stayed that way for the remaining time.

The smell was very strong and beer-like. No layer of hooch.

I was about an hour late today. Here's what I did:

- Stirred down the beast.
- Measured out 1/4 cup and discarded the remaining mixture. (Do you think it will eat away any buildup in my drain?)
- Added 1/4 cup AP flour and 1/4 cup filtered water

It's back in the microwave for ambient warmth. No photo today--not much to see. The surface right now has little bubbles around the edges.

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: Day 3

We have wild yeast, people.

Oh, and he's an aggressive little fellow, too! Look at all those bubbles. The smell... oh, the smell is quite strong. According to everything I've read these are all good signs.

There is no hooch (liquid layer), but that's okay.

Today I added another 2T of AP flour and 2T pineapple puree. I've moved the monster into my microwave. It's getting cold here and we expect some snow, so I wanted to be sure to keep it in a warmish location.

Want to read more about this sourdough experiment?

Day 1
Day 2

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: Day 2

It's starting to smell a little like beer. There are bubbles.


Today I've added another 2 tablespoons of pineapple puree and 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour and mixed it all in with a chopstick. Back on the shelf it goes!

No photo to share today. It looks the same as yesterday, except doubled in volume due to the added flour & pineapple puree.




Sourdough Experiments: Day 1

Monday, October 20, 2008

Sourdough Experiments: Day 1




Did you know that there's wild yeast in the air? It's the very same yeast that causes bread to rise. These wild yeast are regional, too. The widely-known tang of San Francisco's sourdough bread is different from a sourdough made in New York or France.

Upon researching sourdough starter, I learned that there are a good many recipes to try--where to begin? My frugal nature says to use small measurements to avoid too much waste (and there is a great deal of waste when making a sourdough starter), and the only recipe I found that accommodates was at Petite Kitchen.

Here's what I've done today:

I mixed together 2 tablespoons pineapple puree* with 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour (because that's what I have). It went into a cleaned-out cheapo parmesan cheese container with the lid screwed on and the top popped open. It's sitting on my kitchen counter with a rubber band around the top level of the dough for scientific examination. :)

*A friend of mine works at a job where she cuts fruit and, as a result, all the off-sized pieces either go in the trash or are taken home by the kitchen staff. I obtained 1/2 cup of fresh pineapple from her and pureed it with 2 tablespoons of cold water to use for this experiment. The remaining puree is covered in the refrigerator for future use.

You can expect to see a daily starter status update, good or bad, success or fail.


Have you ever made your own sourdough starter? Do you have any suggestions or tips to offer?

LinkWithin Related Stories Widget for Blogs